9 Countries That Had A Hard Time Deleveraging

dellllllllllllllllllllll9 Countries And Their Tumultuous Experiences With Deleveraging
AUG. 27, 2013, 12:47 PM

As China engages with its credit problem, Morgan Stanley’s Jonathan Garner asks in a new note, “Can China achieve a ‘beautiful’ deleveraging?””This phrase was first coined – by Ray Dalio of Bridgewater Associates – to describe a process whereby a country brings a period of excessive credit growth to a halt, and achieves an economic rebalancing, without an overly pronounced or prolonged recession,” said Garner.

JOIN OUR FREE NEWSLETTER TODAY

Plenty governments have tried, but few have succeeded.
“The most successful deleveragings, such as in Korea or the US, were associated with both Net Exports and Consumption making a positive contribution to growth during deleveraging,” Garner writes.
Garner breaks down a few historical examples to see how, when, and why delevering looks “beautiful.”
1. Japan (1990) – “Ugly and then failed deleveraging”
Fiscal deficits and high real interest rates have dogged Japan since its 1990s bust. “Although there was a moderate pickup in growth by 1995, Japan has not in the subsequent 15+ years managed to achieve a successful deleveraging, with chronically low GDP growth (averaging just less than 1% per annum since 1995) and entrenched deflation,” Garner writes.
2. Mexico (1995) – “Chaotic and then more beautiful deleveraging”
Mexico’s deleveraging, though chaotic in the beginning, was relative short-lived thanks in part to a boom in its major trading partner, the US. “It is testament to the power of net exports to turn a chaotic post-Inflexion leveraging situation into something more beautiful.”
3. Indonesia (1998) – “Chaotic deleveraging”Indonesia had a deep recession, with -13.1% GDP growth in 1998. “There was a much bigger reduction in the growth CAGR post-Inflexion than in the case of Mexico or Korea, our other EM comparators,” writes Garner. And: “Real interest rates were exceptionally volatile.”
4. Korea (1998) – “Chaotic and then beautiful deleveraging”
Korea’s East Asian growth model is similar to China, but “Korea had built up a much higher burden of short- to medium-termexternal debt in the mid-1990s than China has today.” Korea’s growth bounced back as the “real policy rate was kept below the real growth rate in four of the five years post-Inflexion.”
5. US (2008) – “Beautiful deleveraging”
After some roadbumps, the US went on a solid macro adjustment path, according to Garner. “First, nominal interest rates were cut dramatically (followed by various rounds of QE). Second, relatively high inflation was tolerated and real interest rates moved into negative territory and stayed there from early 2009.” And real GDP growth exceeded real interest rates.
6. UK (2008) – “Ugly then more beautiful deleveraging”The UK’s slow policy response hurt its recovery, but eventually the real policy rate was moved well into negative territory (-4%, below real GDP growth). “It was a slow grind back, but by mid- 2013 the UK economy was starting to grow quite strongly again.”
7. Spain (2008) – “Failed deleveraging”
Spain’s growth rate plummeted from +4% to -4% and has been negative ever since, Garner notes. “They did not move into negative [real interest rate] territory until 2010, and even then did not sustain a level well below real GDP growth in 2011 and 2012. Spain’s overall leverage to GDP has continued to rise significantly, which is why we classify it as a failed deleveraging.”

8. Ireland (2008) – “Ugly deleveraging”A similar experience to Spain, with real policy rates well above GDP growth in the immediate crisis aftermath, but “unlike Spain, Ireland’s GDP growth rate has returned – just – to positive territory in recent years.”
9. Australia (2009) – “Beautiful so far, but too soon to tell?”
The most recent example, Australia benefitted from the bounce in commodity prices in 1999. “GDP growth itself accelerated back to over 2.0% in 2010 and 2011, rising to a peak of over 4.0% in early 2012; this despite a resumption of real exchange rate appreciation.” But with such strong economic ties to China, it may be too soon to call Australia’s economic situation “beautiful.”
Source: http://www.businessinsider.com/9-different-ways-to-deleverage-2013-8#ixzz2ePeRv9jF

Similar Posts

  • The Traders Expo New York- Adam Sarhan's Next Speaking Engagement

    Dear Trader,
    Trading in volatile markets requires a disciplined approach and there are techniques you can learn to use now that minimize your risk and increase your profits. The secret lies in knowing how consistent traders find trades and manage them well from start to finish. Anyone can learn these strategies—all you need is a commitment to learn what works and the confidence to implement them. The New York Traders Expo is an event packed with non-stop education where you will learn specific technical strategies, how to develop a methodical risk management plan, get tips from world-class experts, and much more!
    Insiders’ analysis of volume, volatility, price, and profit is imperative to keep up with global markets. Every speaker at The Expo is carefully selected because of his or her proven ability to teach trading techniques that can lead to a lifetime of success. Register FREE for The Traders Expo New York, February 20-23, 2011 at the Marriott Marquis Hotel and prepare for four days that will get you on track for a profitable future.
    Join traders from around the world who have said The Expo has made a tremendous difference in their trading. If you make the commitment to attend, you will see how four days in New York could make all the difference in 2011 and beyond. If you gain just one or two new ideas to approach the markets, then the entire trip will have been worth your time!! Register FREE online or by calling 800/970-4355 and mention priority code 021219. We hope that you will join us in New York. For more information visitwww.newyorktradersexpo.com. See you at the Expo!
    Adam Sarhan
    Founder
    The Sarhan Analysis

  • 30 Stocks With Strong Technical Patterns

    The S&P 500 and Dow Jones Industrial Average closed at fresh 2009 highs on Monday. At this point, the major averages are just below important resistance levels for the year (Full commentary here) and appear poised to move higher. If they manage to close above their respective resistance levels on heavy volume then odds will favor a new leg higher will commence. That said, here is a list of 30 stocks that sport strong technical chart patterns:

  • VIX and the S&P 500

    Posted by ddshort.com March 16, 2011Let’s review today’s volatility in the S&P 500. The first chart features an overlay of the index and the CBOE Volatility Index (VIX) since 2007. Today the VIX rose to 29.34, a gain of 20.6% over the previous close.   Click for a larger image As the chart above illustrates, the…